LATENT LIBRARY AI ENGINEERING Evaluating AISystems Metrics, Test Sets and Judgement forModels That Matter LATENT LIBRARY EDITORIAL

Evaluating AI Systems

Metrics, Test Sets and Judgement for Models That Matter

Latent Library Editorial

IntroductionIntroduction

Every AI project reaches the same moment. Someone shows a demo; it handles five questions beautifully; people are impressed; a launch date is set. Then real users arrive with questions nobody anticipated, in phrasings nobody tried, about situations the demo never covered, and the system that looked brilliant turns out to be unreliable in ways nobody measured.

"It looked good in the demo" is not an evaluation. Evaluation is the discipline of measuring, systematically and honestly, whether an AI system does what it is supposed to do, for the people who will actually use it, and whether it keeps doing so over time.

This book covers evaluation for both classic predictive models and generative AI systems:

Exercises with answers and a glossary close the book.

Basic familiarity with machine learning is assumed; every metric is explained with a worked example.

Chapter 1Why Evaluation Is the Real Work

Evaluation drives everything else

Without good evaluation, every other decision is guesswork:

Teams that invest early in evaluation move faster, because each change can be checked in minutes rather than debated for days.

Start from the decision, not the metric

Before choosing metrics, answer:

  1. What will the system's output be used for, and by whom?
  2. What does a good outcome look like for users and the business?
  3. What do different kinds of errors cost? Missing a fraudulent transaction and blocking a legitimate one have very different costs.
  4. What level of performance is needed for the system to be worth using? Compared with what: the current process, a simple rule, a human?

Levels of evaluation

LevelQuestionExample
ComponentDoes each part work?Does retrieval find the right documents?
System (offline)Does the whole system produce good outputs on a test set?Are answers correct and grounded?
User (online)Does it help real users in real use?Do support tickets get resolved faster?
BusinessDoes it achieve the goal?Lower costs, higher satisfaction, more sales?

Each level can look good while the next fails. A model with excellent offline accuracy may not change user behaviour at all. Plan evaluation at every level.

Baselines

Always compare against something: a simple rule, the previous system, a human, or a trivial model (always predicting the most common answer). A model that is 92% accurate sounds impressive until you learn that "always predict no" scores 91%.

You have reached the end of the free sample.
The full book continues with 17 more chapters, plus everything else in its 81 pages.

Get the full book